Do you actually ever has actually a sis? »: Salinger’s Holden Caulfield and Faulkner’s Quentin Compson

Do you actually ever has actually a sis? »: Salinger’s Holden Caulfield and Faulkner’s Quentin Compson

One another possess extremely ambivalent emotions throughout the intercourse: as they speak or think about intercourse almost usually, and also feature to help you anyone else about their sexual knowledge and experience, both are actually scared away from sex, in fact is actually mind-admitted virgins

D. Salinger’s New Catcher about Rye, since identity indicates, was a manuscript constructed on literary the thing is that and you may allusions; this means that, the hero, Holden Caulfield, could have been compared to many almost every other emails, out of one another Western and you may industry literary works.step 1 The nearest regarding Holden’s blood brothers, because the actually a cursory questionnaire of the ailment from Salinger’s novel will show you, can be thought to be Huckleberry Finn.dos And certainly you can find notable likenesses between Huck and Holden: they are both troubled kids on the run–psychologically, linguistically, and you will geographically–off a grown-up world which they get a hold of pretentious, hypocritical, low, cruel, and you may dangerous. step 3 Surprisingly, even when, these stress and anxiety and you may obsessions was only the of these presented by William Faulkner’s Quentin Compson, one of several protagonists of your Voice additionally the Anger. The secret to the fresh neurotic behavior out-of each other characters is found in the Freudian theory of anality, such as for instance while the that principle might have been amplified and reinterpreted because of the instance after psychologists because Norman O. Brownish and you can Ernest Becker. One another Holden and you will Quentin showcase personality traits which can be from the some body whoever development could have been detained in the anal stage.

The surface parallels between the two characters are easily founded, and you can striking. Both are wise, sensitive and painful, introspective, well-informed teenagers: Holden try an effective seventeen-year-old planning university pupil whom reads « a great deal » (18) and you can whoever better topic is actually English (110); Quentin was a keen you are-year-old freshman from the Harvard who knows Latin and quotes St. Francis. cuatro Additionally, one another Holden and you will Quentin project its intimate anxiety on to the sisters, implementing a defensive, « government » thinking and looking so you can pub the new sisters’ entrance for the carnal degree. Fundamentally, its puzzled and interrupted rational claims lead one another Holden and you will Quentin to help you think of suicide.5 Quentin, definitely, in place of Holden, actually comes after because of on his passing need to, purchasing a pair of apartment-irons getting human body loads immediately after which hurling himself off a link into Charles Lake.

But the most significant specifics of Holden Caulfield’s characterization –their paralyzing fear of sex, their excessively protective thinking towards the their sister, with his unhealthy preoccupation which have demise–is actually shed from inside the Twain’s portrait off Huck

Since the ideal before, the fresh unifying emotional basis fundamental both Holden and you will Quentin’s anxieties of sex, people, and you will demise is usually to be based in the Freudian idea of anality. Based on Freud, the explanation of the many mature neurosis is going to be used in the fresh suppressed sexual wants away from youngsters. Freud posited three level from infantile intimate invention: the oral (birth to help you twelve months), between your situations out of sucking and you can biting; the new anal (that three-years), focusing on the latest children’s fascination with new anus and you will stools; and also the phallic (two-and-a-half so you can half a dozen age), emphasizing the fresh new children’s knowledge of pussy. When your child’s passage compliment of each of these phases is not negotiated effectively and you will happily, the newest repressed drives usually resurface within the adulthood in the form of certain neuroses. Based on Freud, the fresh new mature characteristics which can be of this denial and you will repression within the anal stage are orderliness (also neatness), obstinacy, and you will parsimony (or possessiveness).six

To possess Freud, anal curiosity and gamble, such as the kid’s actions inside almost every other phase of infantile invention, are primarily assertions of the pleasure concept along side reality and you will morality values–exactly what do be considered from inside the retrospect since useless attempts from the kid to stick so you’re able to an Edenic world of simple independence and you can play in the face of coming exile on the mature arena of really works and you will obligations. But later psychologists eg Norman O. Brown and you can Ernest Becker has aided us to understand that the issue is considerably more difficult than simply actually Freud got approved. Inside the insightful and you can important book, Lifetime Up against Passing, Brown contends one to what’s most being stamped to the consciousness of any folks during the anal stage is nothing reduced than just « the brand new argument ranging from the animal muscles, appropriately epitomized regarding anal form, and you may all of our pretentious sublimations, more specifically the pretensions off sublimated otherwise intimate-Platonic like » (186). Put simply, the brand new rectal standing represents brand new child’s earliest stumble on that have death and you can decay. Just like the Becker notes, echoing Brownish, « Which have anal have fun with the boy is becoming a beneficial philosopher regarding the human reputation. However, like all philosophers he could be nevertheless limited by it, and his awesome head activity in life becomes brand new denial away from what the newest arse means: one to indeed, he or she is simply human body in which character is concerned. Nature’s viewpoints is real beliefs, person viewpoints try intellectual opinions, and even though it grab the loftiest routes he could be built up on excrement, impossible without it, usually brought back to help you they » (31). The latest argument educated because of the kid within anal stage, for this reason, is that of the human body as opposed to your body and mind or spirit, the real as opposed to a suitable.